« Straight Talk on Islam | Main | Changes in the Land »

Comments

Dave,

Interesting article. He raises some good points about the Constitutional issues--though some think that debate is already settled. Frankly I think the early Utah cases were wrongly decided.

The problem today is that so much of the practice is rife with welfare fraud, underage marriage and child abuse. It's hard to justify a free exercise argument in those cases.

I'm curious to see how well the state's case holds up when it comes time for Jane Doe to actually face the jury. In the Barlow case (another criminal prosecution) the star witness has now refused to testify, and had even been jailed for contempt. I think she has been released--but the judge has given the prosecution only so much time to get her to play ball, or risk dismissal.

The other thing I've wondered but haven't really nailed down quite yet, is what about the actual husband of this Jane Doe? Was he arrested--if not why, and what was the disposition in his case, if any?

Thanks for the post.

They'll never indict a guy like Jeffs for polygamy. A couple of crafty appeals later, and the Supreme Court would rule that it is not unconstitutional to practice it. Nobody wants that, so they always nail these guys with other charges like abetting a rape or child abuse or whatever. At least that's what I've concluded.

David J, the reason they don't generally indict "a guy like Jeffs for polygamy" is because he can't be convicted of polygamy. That would require the state to demonstrate that he entered into more than one legal marriage. Since his "plural wives" aren’t legal wives, he's only guilty of shacking up. The state had to go through some extensive manuvering to convict Tom Green and they needed his statements on videotape to accomplish that. That’s why prosecutions against polygamists historically have not been about polygamy. It was “unlawful cohabitation” for 19th century Mormons and “sending obscene material through the mail” and “crossing state lines for immoral purposes” for fundamentalists like Rulon Jeffs (dismissed at arraignment) Joseph Musser, Rulon Allred and others.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Now Reading

Blog powered by Typepad

General Books 09-12

General Books 06-08

General Books 04-05

About This Site

Mormon Books 2013-14

Mormon Books 2012

Science Books

Bible Books

Mormon Books 09-11

Mormon Books 2008

Mormon Books 2007

Mormon Books 2006

Mormon Books 2005

Religion Books 09-12

Religion Books 2008

Religion Books 2004-07